Pizza a Way of Life at Romanelli's on Lincoln

Eatery a Madison landmark going on five decades.

Now in its fifth decade serving the people of Madison, at 42 Lincoln Place must be doing something right.

For its loyal following in the area, that something is pizza.

Now, it’s a truism if you live in northern New Jersey, you’ll likely be eating a lot of pizza. Especially in the summer when the need to relax is great and the desire for many to cook is, well, not as great.

And, in a region where each town has a half-dozen pizzerias—or more—from which to choose, the typical diner can soon find his tastebuds glossing over at the thought of yet another doughy pie.

Not so with Romanelli’s.

It’s worth noting that Romanelli’s offers pies in three sizes—a 12-inch, 16-inch medium and 18-inch jumbo. That alone puts the purveyor out in front, with pies for any appetite, including kids’. That solves a culinary conundrum for parents: A large pie usually isn’t enough, or you’ve got so much left over you wished you’d ordered slices instead.

Now, Patch has always prided itself on its love of a good, basic cheese pizza. But, dear Lord, how Romanelli’s is changing that esthetic. A quick look at the menu reveals a selection of 21 — 21! — specialty pizzas, in any of the aforementioned three sizes, to boot. They range from the four-cheese with mozzarella, provolone, romano and seasoned ricotta to the Hawaiian with ham and pineapple chunks, to the stuffed meat double-crust masterpiece with pepperoni, ham, sausage and meatball AND four cheeses, the last available only in the jumbo 18-inch model, as it should be.  Did we mention a full range of pies rendered in whole wheat crust? Prices range from $8.45 for a small cheese pizza up to $18.70 for the jumbo meat lover’s pie.

Romanelli’s also caters to those seeking more than pizza with enticing sandwiches, wraps , calzone, stromboli, paninis and hot and cold subs and entrees, for those diners who choose not to indulge their pizza jones. There are more than a few gems here, too: The selection of Supermelts feature homemade pita bread; a BBQ pulled pork hot sub with fries is new on the menu. Oh, don’t forget the jumbo wings, available up to an 80-piece tray.

Romanelli’s also offers catering and party facilities, call 973-377-9515.

Patrick Franklin August 12, 2011 at 02:43 AM
I've always been a fan of Romanelli's for their variety and quick delivery. I remember when it was located on Main St. Not quite sure what 42 Lincoln was before Romanelli's, perhaps an auto garage or something....can't quite remember
Steve T. August 12, 2011 at 04:34 AM
No idea Patrick, but I enjoyed visiting Sweet Dreams next door to Romanelli's some years ago - that was a pretty neat place in its day. I believe the below linked article captures the essence of it - http://charlottetriggs.blogspot.com/2004/05/sweet-dreams-cafe-fans-wake-to.html


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something